Economists under Pressure and the Political Limits to Economics

From insularity to integration: Understanding genuine interdisciplinarity in economics

van Lookeren Campagne Lodewijk, Wageningen Social & Economic Research (WUR)

This paper looks at how institutional and epistemological pressures within economics have shaped, and at times limited, the production of economic knowledge. Histories of economic thought often focus on external political forces, such as censorship, ideology, or state control, but pressures also come from within the discipline itself. Hierarchies of prestige, concentrated publication in elite journals, and narrow peer-review processes create strong incentives to follow established methods. These pressures discourage economists from engaging deeply with other disciplines and reinforce a cycle in which superficial engagement leads to methodological insularity and dismissiveness. Using Uskali Mäki’s framework of ontological, pragmatic, epistemological and institutional constraints, the paper develops a model for understanding how economists navigate the tension between disciplinary autonomy and openness to other fields. Economics has long been unusually inward-looking among the social sciences, with limited exchange with neighbouring disciplines and a strong reliance on formal modelling. Surveys and citation analyses show that economists often view their field as more “scientific” than others, reinforcing hierarchies and discouraging cross-disciplinary curiosity. These pressures act as a kind of self-imposed control within the discipline. Common criticisms of economists include oversimplifying complex phenomena, relying too heavily on quantification, and ignoring qualitative insights. A case study of the ‘Out of Africa’ hypothesis by Quamrul Ashraf and Oded Galor shows how these pressures play out in practice, leading to reductionist interpretations, defensive responses to critique, and limited engagement with other sciences. By examining these internal pressures, the paper broadens the idea of “economists under pressure” to include not only external political forces but also the discipline’s own structures. It also considers ways economists could engage more openly with other fields, for example through deeper collaboration and attention to methods and findings from related disciplines, which might help avoid the cycle of superficial interdisciplinarity and improve the quality of research.

Area:

Keywords: Interdisciplinarity in economics, Institutional constraints, Methodological insularity, Academic self-censorship, Pluralism in economics

Please Login in order to download this file